All / Candy / Caramel All New Arrivals Candy Boxes Seasonal Candy Bulk Bags Gummies Marshmallow Spicy Sour Lollipops Fruity Caramel Bubblegum Licorice Retro International Mixed Bags Chocolate Snacks Clothing / Merchandise Sugar Babies Caramel Apple Theatre Box $3.50 Add To Cart Curly Wurly $1.69 Sold Out Add To Cart Reeds $1.99 Select Flavour Root Beer Butterscotch Add To Cart M&Ms Caramel Cold Brew $2.99 Add To Cart Tootsie Caramel Apple Pops $0.89 Add To Cart Cow Tales $1.29 Select Flavour Oreo Caramel Apple Original Caramel Caramel Brownie Honey Bun Add To Cart